homee-mailPrint
Commercial Lighting Tax Deduction

Technologies > HID ELECTRONIC BALLASTS



Description: Electronic HID ballasts combine the ballast, capacitor, ignitor and mounting brackets into a single unit, and operate HID lamps more efficiently than conventional magnetic ballasts. Operating a ceramic metal halide lamp, the use of an electronic ballast can increase energy savings by 5-25 percent than a system using a magnetic ballast.

Characteristics: Electronic HID ballasts are steadily increasing in applications and versatility while decreasing in size and cost. Meanwhile, lamp and ballast manufacturers are partnering on joint dedicated lamp and ballast development.

Wattages have been expanding, with ballasts now available for 20W, 39W, 50W, 70W, 100W, 150W, 175W, 200W, 250W, 320W, 400W and 450W lamps. One manufacturer estimates that 39W and 70W lamp applications make up 50 percent of the electronic HID market, but sees accelerating growth in conversion of 400W metal halide lamp and magnetic ballast applications to 250W, 320W or 350W systems due to the lamp lumen depreciation benefits and energy savings derived from use of electronic HID ballasts.

A number of models now offer versatile multi-wattage and multi-voltage operation. HID electronic ballasts with multi-wattage capability and an ability to run on 208-277 volts provide a heightened level of application versatility.

Meanwhile, ballasts have steadily been decreasing in size, as shown in Table 1 below. Since 1998, typical ballast volume has decreased by 25-75 percent, depending on the wattage. Miniaturization is expected to allow the pairing of HID electronic ballasts with ceramic metal halide lamps, which will present a compelling energy savings story for retailers currently using halogen lighting. It has also enabled the introduction of smaller fixture designs in track lighting.

Table 2. Progression of electronic HID ballast miniaturization. The table shows a comparison of typical ballast volume in cubic centimeters. Source: “Emerging HID Technologies,” Lightfair 2005 seminar.

Wattage

1998-2002

2003-2004

2005-2006

39W

420 cm 3

170 cm 3

105 cm 3

70W

420 cm 3

330 cm 3

205 cm 3

100W

420 cm 3

420 cm 3

310 cm 3

150W

1100 cm 3

650 cm 3

420 cm 3


Dimming ballasts are currently available for higher-wattage lamps from 250 to 400W, particularly suitable for applications designed to benefit from daylight harvesting.

While the average cost of magnetic HID ballasts has been slowly increasing since the late 1990s, the average cost of electronic HID ballasts has been steadily declining. As costs are reduced, the electronic option becomes more cost-effective and competitive.

Applications: Interest in electronic HID ballasts is growing for both low-wattage and high-wattage lamps, as these ballasts prove competitive against incandescent and halogen lamps as well as standard HID systems. Currently, retail is the leading application for HID electronic ballasts, in conjunction with more ceramic metal halide lamps being used for accent lighting in retail applications.

Advantages: Electronic HID ballasts offer a number of benefits that can save energy and increase quality. In Table 2 (below), we see several electronically ballasted ceramic metal halide systems compared to comparable magnetic and halogen incandescent systems. The use of an electronic ballast can increase energy savings by 5-25 percent.

Table 2. System comparison: system watts @120V (lamp watts). Source: “Emerging HID Technologies,” Lightfair 2005 seminar by Helen K. Diemer, FIALD, The Lighting Practice, Manuel Oomen, PhD, Philips Lighting and John Cummings, Advance.

System

System Watts @120V (Lamp Watts)

System Watts @120V (Lamp Watts)

System Watts @120V (Lamp Watts)

Halogen Incandescent

75W (75W)

100W (100W)

150W (150W)

Ceramic MH/Magnetic

N/A

50W (39W)

72W (50W)

Ceramic MH/Electronic

26W (20W)

45W (39W)

50W (50W)


In addition, electronic HID ballasts allow for substantially more fixtures per circuit, lumen depreciation improvement (allowing lower-wattage lamps), constant lamp power (tighter regulation of lamp performance regardless of voltage variation), quiet operation, consistent color for ceramic metal halide lamps, maximized lamp life, elimination of flickering, and lamp monitoring with automatic shutoff at end of life (which can improve safety).

Disadvantages: Electronic HID ballasts are more sensitive to extreme temperatures and are not necessarily suitable for use in every application where magnetic HID was used previously.

Be careful when attempting to pair high-frequency electronic ballasts with ceramic metal halide lamps. Ceramic metal halide lamps will operate only on a low-frequency ballast design.

In addition, application of HID dimming electronic ballasts is somewhat limited due to availability in a limited range of wattages (although manufacturers estimate that within the next few years dimming will be available in all wattages), and also limited in color-critical applications due to color shift that occurs during dimming on some ballasts.


See also:

Pulse-Start Metal Halide

Ceramic Metal Halide Lamps

Metal Halide Tracklights

Contact Us | Partners | EfficientBuildings.org | Disclaimer
©2006 NEMA | All Rights Reserved | About NEMA